Queen of Pendleton Case Update: Rice v. Rabb2020-04-23T00:25:21+00:00
Queen of Pendleton Case Update: Rice v. Rabb


The Supreme Court issued an important decision about statutes of limitations under Oregon law on January 30, 2014.  In Rice v. Rabb, 354 Or 721 (2014) the Court held that there is a discovery rule for conversion claims under ORS 12.080(4) and reversed the Court of Appeals, which held that Rice’s conversion claim was time-barred because plaintiff sued more than six years after the tort, the taking of the Queen of the Pendleton Round-Up outfit, was committed.   (See our previous post about the Court of Appeals opinion in that case for the full round-up of the facts.)  The Supreme Court concluded that Rice’s claims “accrued” when she obtained the knowledge of the tort committed on her by Rabb.  Because Rice did not know that Rabb had taken the outfit until 2007, years after Rabb took the outfit, her claim did not accrue until then.

Construction defects and damage caused by construction defects are often not immediately perceptible to owners.  Based on the reasoning of Rice v. Rabb, claims for negligent construction under ORS 12.080(3) are likely subject to a discovery rule and claims for breach of contract under ORS 12.080(1) may also be subject to a discovery rule.  Cases currently pending before the Court of Appeals may answer those questions.


Ball Janik LLP was founded in 1982 with six lawyers and a four-person support staff in Portland, Oregon. Since our firm’s inception, we have expanded our capabilities, our professionals, and geographic footprint. What started as a firm focused in real property and land use (known then as Ball Janik & Novack), has grown to include the insights of a team of 30-plus attorneys, with a combined six centuries of experience, and capabilities including Real Estate and Land Use, Construction Defect, Commercial Litigation, Insurance Recovery, Construction and Design, Employment, Finance and Corporate, Public Agencies and Schools, and Community Associations. With offices in Florida and Oregon, our regional growth has earned us a national reputation for upholding the rights of our clients.

Ball Janik LLP has been recognized by Chambers USA, U.S. News & World Report and Best Lawyers®, The Best Lawyers in America©, and Corporate International. Ball Janik LLP’s success and integrity have repeatedly made it one of “Oregon’s Most Admired Professional Firms,” according to the Portland Business Journal’s survey results of CEOs throughout the region.

Heather J. Oden
Oregon , Portland
No Blog Tiles found.